Hook to Plate

Go Fish: Cook Up Your Catch on Siesta Key's Only Beachfront Playground

By Cooper Levey-Baker / Photography By Kathryn Brass-Piper | Last Updated July 01, 2015
Share to printerest Share to fb Share to twitter Share to mail Share to print
go fiesta siesta keys

Waking up outdoors feels like magic. It’s even more sublime if you’re doing it on Siesta Key and Evan Gastman is making breakfast.

Gastman—the chef at The Cottage and The Hub, both on Siesta—slides a rectangle of foil with crimped-up sides onto the blistering grate of a propane grill set up at campsite number 20 of Siesta’s county-owned Turtle Beach Campground. Inside the package: filets of sea trout, bathed in lemon juice and a touch of Liquid Smoke and decorated with kosher salt and long strands of dill. Over top goes an upside-down, crazy-hot cast iron skillet, creating a small pocket of extreme heat. Little clouds of hot air waft here and there away from the grill. The foil sizzles. Stomachs rumble.

The goal today is simple. A group of guys has gathered to hang out, catch some fish and eat them. Gastman is doing the heavy lifting on the cooking end. Scott Dolan of Big Water Fish Market is on hand, too, delivering filets from his collection of exceptional Gulf species when the fish aren’t biting. And Todd Piper, the manager of Siesta Sports Rentals, has brought kayaks and other gear to keep everyone afloat.

But before they can go fishing, they need to wake up. Coffee helps, as does a jug of Bloody Marys. As the fish on the grill smokes away, Gastman cracks eggs into a small Tupperware box then shakes the plastic to break up the yolks. He pops the lid off a jar of sriracha and dumps a dose over a mix of mascarpone and more lemon juice. Once the fish has cooked through, Gastman flips the cast iron right side up and tosses in a thick brick of butter. The eggs go in next.

“It’s a twist on the same dish with smoked salmon,” New York native Gastman says about this morning’s recipe. “It’s an homage to my childhood.” The result blends the subtle smoke from the grill, the soft richness of the slowly scrambled eggs and the smooth lactose of the cheese.

And that’s just breakfast. While everyone is chowing down, Gastman’s already working on lunch, mixing a whole box of Morton salt with egg whites and chopped dill and chives into a thick slurry. He spreads a quarter of that paste onto the bottom of another foil pouch then places a whole bar jack on top of the mixture. He covers the glistening fish with the rest of the salt. After just a few minutes on the grill, the salt blend has already begun forming the brown crust that will encase the fish’s flesh and keep it moist as it bakes.

Breakfast has disappeared. Lunch will be here soon. For now, there’s nothing to do but hit the water. Grab your reel.

Big Water Fish Market: 6641 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota; 941-554-8101; bigwaterfishmarket.com

Siesta Sports Rentals: 6551 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota; 941-346-1797; siestasportsrentals.com

The Cottage: 153 Avenida Messina, Sarasota; 941-312-9300; cottagesiestakey.com

The Hub Baja-Grill: 5148 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota; 941-349-6800; thehubsiestakey.com

Build your own subscription bundle.
Pick 3 regions for $60
We will never share your email address with anyone else. See our privacy policy.